GAINESVILLE, Fla. (AP) – An insurance coverage firm is suing the mom of two boys killed by their estranged husband over a $ 4 million life insurance coverage payout alleging she might not have been legally entitled to obtain it. She is now making an attempt to lift $ 10 million from her husband’s property.
The lawsuit that’s at the moment underway in federal court docket is the most recent twist within the crime earlier this yr. It sheds new mild on the daddy’s deeds days earlier than the murders and factors to the big sums of cash at stake for surviving members of the family.
Paul Reinhart, 46, of Gainesville, shot and killed the couple’s younger sons on Could 4 earlier than setting fireplace to the household’s trip dwelling close to Suwannee, western Florida and taking pictures himself.
Courtroom data within the new lawsuit confirmed that Reinhart – a former medical gadget gross sales director – on the 26. They had been separated on the time and had been en path to a divorce.
The insurance policies had been valued at $ 2 million every and had been bought in 2005 and 2015. They allowed full payouts for suicide so long as Reinhart hadn’t killed himself for at the least two years after the acquisition.
With the adjustments, Reinhart tried to designate his sons Rex, 14) and Brody (11) as the primary beneficiaries. Once they died, Reinhart recognized one among his brothers, Konrad Reinhart, 45, of Gainesville, because the second beneficiary. Paul Reinhart has signed a notarized doc with the requested adjustments to Constancy Investments Life Insurance coverage Co.
Reinhart’s actions add to the proof suggesting that he deliberate the lethal violence days upfront. Information in a associated probate litigation confirmed that Reinhart signed his will on Jan.
In a associated dispute over this modification to the desire, Ms. Reinhart’s attorneys stated in court docket data that Konrad Reinhart knew or ought to have recognized that her husband was planning violence due to Reinhart’s actions within the days earlier than his loss of life.
Constancy wrote to Reinhart in a letter dated 30. The corporate’s “Beneficiary Change Kind” didn’t state within the doc that data was required.
It was unclear whether or not Reinhart had acquired the letter from Constancy – posted by the corporate’s life insurance coverage workplaces in Atlanta – earlier than he shot his sons and himself 4 days later. A closing report on the felony investigation of two sheriff’s workplaces and the Florida Division of Legislation Enforcement into the case has been mysteriously delayed for months.
Mrs. Reinhart declined to debate the brand new lawsuit by one among her attorneys, Jeff Aaron of Grey Robinson in Orlando. She continued to have fun the reminiscence of her sons on social media, posting footage earlier this month of a brand new bench in Suwannee devoted to Rex and Brody that was arrange close to a bridge they had been swimming on. She flew to Washington along with her dad and mom in late September to attend the Congress baseball recreation.
In her lawsuit, filed earlier this month, Constancy stated Ms. Reinhart utilized by her lawyer for $ 4 million in unpaid curiosity on Could 14.
Six weeks later, based on the insurance coverage firm, Konrad Reinhart inquired about his brother’s life insurance coverage funds and stated he must be the one surviving beneficiary beneath the adjustments his brother requested.
Constancy stated it has stopped paying the $ 4 million checks it despatched to Ms. Reinhart. It was stated that she and Konrad Reinhart had agreed that the cash could be transferred to a checking account managed by Constancy’s legislation agency till a decide decides who will obtain the cash. Within the new lawsuit, each Ms. Reinhart and Konrad Reinhart had been named as defendants.
Ms. Reinhart’s legislation agency wrote in a letter dated August 3 that it was awaiting litigation in opposition to Reinhart’s property. On the time, the household was already battling over the $ 4 million and associated issues behind the scenes, however the life insurance coverage dispute – and the dimensions of the payout – has not been made public till now.
Months in the past, Konrad Reinhart threatened a reporter who known as to ask a couple of associated matter. “Should you name that quantity once more it is going to be an enormous downside,” he stated in early September. “Cease calling me.” He and his attorneys didn’t reply to cellphone messages this week.
In court docket recordsdata, the insurance coverage firm described itself as a “merely disinterested actor” and stated it was “vulnerable to a number of legal responsibility” except a decide decides the case. It careworn that it was not making an attempt to maintain the $ 4 million.
Within the probate course of, Ms. Reinhart filed a US $ 10 million lawsuit in opposition to her husband’s property in September, citing the “illegal loss of life by homicide” of her sons. This case is pending in Alachua County District Courtroom.
On this case, Konrad Reinhart fought Ms. Reinhart’s efforts to acquire confidential recordsdata from Withers Harvey, the Gainesville legislation agency that was modifying the up to date will that excluded her. In court docket recordsdata, Konrad Reinhart’s attorneys stated final week that these recordsdata had been protected by lawyer confidentiality.
Ms. Reinhart’s attorneys had beforehand contradicted a request by Konrad Reinhart to divide the property between Reinhart and Ms. Reinhart’s 5 siblings. Konrad Reinhart’s lawyer estimated the property to be price $ 75,000 in private property. He didn’t checklist financial institution accounts, investments or different belongings.
Konrad Reinhart’s utility listed himself, a sister and three brothers as beneficiaries earlier than Ms. Reinhart was additionally included within the court docket recordsdata. His lawyer named Erick von Reinhart, 50, who pleaded responsible to an impartial crime of fatally stabbing his personal ex-wife’s new boyfriend – only a week after their divorce – after which tried to get together with an enormous one Kitchen knife to take life.
Erick Reinhart is serving a 40-year homicide sentence in a Florida jail and may very well be launched as early as July 2053.
Final month, Ms. Reinhart accomplished the sale of the $ 1.65 million Gainesville dwelling she shared along with her husband earlier than the break up to a chemical business government. She used the proceeds to repay a $ 900,000 mortgage on the home on October 15, data confirmed.
The household nonetheless personal the Dixie County waterfront dwelling the place the murders and fires occurred, based on property data.
This story was produced by Contemporary Take Florida, a information service for the College of Florida Faculty of Journalism and Communications. The reporters might be reached at [email protected] and [email protected]